An insole is a simple assistive device that is inserted into the shoe. It’s purpose is to absorb shocks and promote proper foot alignment in order to alleviate pain associated with various foot conditions.
Insoles have come a long way in the past 50 years. They are now available in an array of specialty designs intended to address specific conditions such as plantar fasciitis, overpronation and more.
But while choice is good there are so many different insoles on the market today that finding the right one can be a daunting task. But fear not. We’ve done the homework for you and brought together this list of the 10 best insoles of 2020.
1. Dr. Scholl’s Pain Relief Orthotics
When it comes to consumer grade foot care products Dr. Scholl’s is ubiquitous. That’s mainly because they have a habit of producing high-quality products at affordable prices. Their Pain Relief Orthotics are yet another feather in their feather-laden cap. Comfortable, versatile and effective they’re great insoles for alleviating general foot pain and discomfort.
What we like: We like the dependable quality of these insoles. The Shock Guard actually does a good job absorbing shocks and relieves the pain associated with spending hours on your feet.
We also like that they fit easily into different types of footwear and that they’re easy to trim (if necessary). If your shoes are getting you down these will definitely help.
Flaws: Don’t get confused by the name. These are insoles, not custom orthotics. On a practical note, they’re relatively thick in the heel so you may have to remove any factory installed inserts to make them fit.
2. Wernies Running Shoe Inserts
Wernies may not have the brand recognition of Dr. Scholl’s but their Running Shoe Inserts are right up there in the quality department. They’re made for runners and to address runner-related maladies like plantar fasciitis, shin splints, heel pain and more. Slip a pair of these into your athletic shoes and you’re good to go for the whole day.
What we like: The arch support doesn’t waver throughout the day. We like that. They’re durable and comfortable and don’t irritate the sole of your foot. We like the job the gel pads do absorbing shocks. And the heel cup really stabilizes your foot to promote good posture and proper motion.
Flaws: If you have wide feet you may find these a bit narrow. Also, if you’re expecting these to be cushy soft you’ll be disappointed. They’re pretty firm.
3. Hydrofeet Liquid Massaging Insoles
Hydrofeet Liquid Massaging Insoles sound like a gimmick. But they’re nothing to laugh at. While the ‘massaging’ qualities of these insoles may leave something to be desired they otherwise deliver for those who spend all day on their feet. Even if you just get sore feet walking through the market on the weekend these will help.
What we like: There’s no denying that these insoles provide robust cushioning for tired feet. We were also pleasantly surprised by the level of arch support. The fact that you can toss them in the washing machine is also a big plus.
Flaws: They might be a bit too cushy for some folks. And they are not the most durable insoles on the market.
4. Physix Full Length Orthotic Inserts
Physix Full Length Orthotic Inserts promise the sun and the moon and mostly deliver. That by itself makes them worth the price of admission. They’re fashioned from PU leather and EVA foam and the combination is very comfortable and provides good to outstanding support through the arch. They cost a bit more but if the stability of your shoes is an issue these will help.
What we like: We like the level of arch support you get from these insoles. We appreciate how agreeable they feel against the sole of the foot. The materials seem first rate and they fit easily into a variety of shoe types. Also, the heel cup does a good job promoting stability even though there isn’t much padding underpinning it.
Flaws: The cushioning in the heel is pretty modest, which kind of surprised us. And you may have to trim them a bit to fit them into your shoes.
5. Foot Active Arch Support Insoles
Not the most attractive insoles on our list the Foot Active Arch Support Insoles are nonetheless effective and affordable. Which means they’re a good value. They’re particularly helpful for those with fallen arches or who suffer from heel pain. The materials and build quality are first rate and they’re bound to last a good long time.
What we like: The degree of support these insoles give the arch of the foot is pretty impressive. They cradle your feet and promote a proper gait. If you suffer from plantar fasciitis these should certainly help. They’re also light, sleek and will fit neatly into your dress shoes.
Flaws: Not for waiters or nurses or others who spend long hours on their feet. Unless they suffer from plantar fasciitis. Why? Just not enough cushioning.
6. Walk Hero Plantar Fasciitis Feet Insoles
If you have arch-related foot pain these Walk Hero insoles are likely to provide relief. The cushioning isn’t going to set any records but the support from the ball of the foot through the arch to the heel is hard to beat. They’re compatible with all kinds of shoes and best of all they won’t break your bank.
What we like: We really like the gentle but unmistakable way these insoles take control of your feet. Also, we appreciate that the fabric avoids turning your shoes into sweat boxes. And that the insoles stay put once you place them inside your shoes. A big plus.
Flaws: Great for people with arch or heel pain. Maybe not so great for those with more general foot pain caused by long hours standing up.
7. Spenco Polysorb Insoles
The Spenco Polysorb Insoles have a somewhat unusual profile but somehow they leverage that unique shape to produce outstanding support and comfort. They’ll cost you a bit more than some other insoles. But if your feet tire easily after a short time in your shoes you should give them a whirl. They’ll likely help.
What we like: If you are looking for a combination of cushioning and arch support you’ll get it from these Spenco insoles. They’re very comfy, fit in various types of shoes and do a great job absorbing shocks over the course of the day. The forefoot crashpad and heel pad are big reasons for that outstanding shock absorption.
Flaws: They may be too thick to put into athletic shoes. And while we like the forefoot crashpad it’s likely to be the first point of failure.
8. Hyperspace Plantar Fasciitis Arch Support Insoles
If you work on your feet you know only too well how walking all day can stress your foot, leg and back muscles. These Hyperspace insoles are marketed as providing plantar fasciitis relief. And they’ll do a good job of that. But they also provide good to very good relief from the everyday stress and strain your feet and legs experience.
What we like: We agree with the marketing that these do a good job correcting overpronation. They’re also comfortable and well-made as well as being very affordable. They’re one of the few we’d confidently recommend for use in hiking boots as the cushioning is first rate.
Flaws: They’re pretty thick so you will likely have to remove any factory installed inserts if you want to use them.
9. Superfeet Carbon Insoles
Superfeet Carbon Insoles are all about correcting foot alignment and providing arch support. They’re not intended for nurses or construction workers who just need some cushioning to get through the day. They’re for people with pronation or supination issues or those who suffer from plantar fasciitis. And for what they are they do a great job.
What we like: These are good for people who just want a bit more support than their shoes are providing. They do a decent job alleviating arch and heel pain and promoting proper foot alignment. And they’re thin enough to fit into your finest shoes.
Flaws: They provide very little support for the ball of the foot. Also, for the price we expected them to be a bit more comfortable than they are.
10. Kaps Premium Orthotic Leather Insoles
We included a number of insoles on our list that provide cushioning for people that are on their feet all day. These are not one of them. Kaps Premium Orthotic Leather Insoles are for those with fallen arches or those who suffer from plantar fasciitis. They’re built to last, keep your feet surprisingly cool and aren’t recycling nightmares.
What we like: Those who just want some extra support under their arch will appreciate these. They’re well made, fairly rigid and thin enough for all your shoes. They’re one of the few insoles you’ll find made from a natural material (leather in this case). And they’re one of the most durable as well.
Flaws: Those who want lots of cushioning are not going to find it here. These are strictly arch support insoles.
Who Needs Insoles?
You have a plethora of shoe choices today. More than at any time in history. Not only do you have more shoes to pick from but you have more specialized shoes to pick from than ever before. Need a shoe just for weightlifting? No problem. A shoe for running? Got it. Hot about ‘golf sandals’ or hiking boots for diabetics or maybe shoes specifically designed for badminton? Got it, got it, got it.
However, in spite of the fact that high quality specialty shoes abound, almost none of these shoes effectively address common foot problems like overpronation (1), oversupination (2), plantar fasciitis (3) or flat feet (4). And that’s where insoles come in. While some manufacturers place inserts into their shoes most of them are of little practical use for someone with one of the above listed conditions. You need the type of insoles on our list.
These insoles occupy a middle ground between factory installed inserts and custom made orthotics (5). The terms ‘insoles’ and ‘orthotics’ are often used interchangeably (and you’ll see that in the brand names on our list), but they are really two different things. Insoles are an OTC item while orthotics are typically custom designed by your doctor specifically for your feet.
How We Ranked
Because different foot conditions call for different remedies all commercially available insoles cannot be examined under the same light. As such, what we were looking for wasn’t necessarily X amount of padding in the heel. Instead we focused on overall build quality, whether they were durable and whether they represented a good value.
Of course, if an insole said it would alleviate pain and discomfort associated with plantar fasciitis (for instance) then we expected it to do just that. If it didn’t then it didn’t make our list. In addition, we were partial to insoles that fit easily into various types of footwear. Because, while it’s not uncommon for people to have to trim back an insole a bit in order to fit it into their shoe, it’s always better if you don’t have to do that. Because cutting back an insole can sometimes undermine its effectiveness.
Finally, we wanted our list to represent a cross section of different firmness levels. Because some people will need a rigid insole, some will need a semi-rigid and others will want and need a more cushioned insole.
Insoles help relieve foot pain. This is why you buy insoles to begin with. So if they don’t alleviate pain there’s something wrong. Good insoles will effectively address your particular foot issue and in doing so nullify the cause of your pain and discomfort. Whether the problem is a collapsed arch or arches, plantar fasciitis or just wear and tear caused by years of running, crossfit or other physical activity. Insoles absorb and redistribute pressure exerted on the foot, or they provide your arches with a firm underpinning. Whatever the issue with your foot there is an insole that can help.
Insoles support your arches. Just like the arches that support ancient Roman aqueducts (6) the job of the arches in your feet is to absorb and redistribute weight. If that sounds familiar it’s because that’s exactly what insoles are designed to do too. You use insoles when your own arches have lost the ability to absorb the forces associated with walking, running or doing anything else on your feet. There are a lot of reasons why someone’s arches may have fallen. But whatever the exact cause insoles like the ones profiled above can step in (so to speak) and fill the support void.
Insoles make developing foot problems less likely. That’s why a lot of people who don’t have any particular problem with their feet wear insoles anyway. Insoles can help ensure that they don’t develop fallen arches, shin splints, plantar fasciitis or bunions (7). The fact is a lot of foot problems are preventable. They’re the result of improper foot movement or low-quality footwear or simply overuse. If you are worried that you may be developing issues with your feet the sooner you get some high quality insoles and start wearing them the better.
Insoles produce a positive effect throughout the body. Just as good teeth lead to more complete chewing, better digestion, better nutrient absorption and better health so too healthy feet promote strong legs. Your feet and legs don’t exist in separate worlds. They are inextricably linked and have a direct effect on one another. If your feet are in poor shape it will cause unnatural stresses on your legs that could lead to ankle, knee or hip injury. Or muscle strains, ligament tears and more. Using insoles to re-establish a healthy relationship between feet and legs can have myriad benefits. Research even suggests that strong legs mean a strong, active mind when you get older (8). So wear your insoles, keep your legs strong and stay mentally sharp.
Insoles can help prevent shin splints. Shin splints (9) is a blanket term that describes pain that radiates up and down the front of the shin. The pain is the result of microscopic tears in the muscles and bone tissue in the lower leg. A common cause of shin splints is going from not exercising at all to doing too much too quickly. Older folks who decide to get in shape after years of inactivity sometimes fall victim to shin splints. As do those with fallen arches, another common cause of this condition. Insoles can help prevent shin splints. And if you’ve already developed them, insoles can help reduce the pain they produce.
Insoles can help reduce back pain. Strong feet and legs go a long way toward ensuring a strong back. One that is less prone to injury and less susceptible to everyday aches and pains. When feet are not well-served by the shoes a person wears, or because of extraordinary stresses and strains caused by exercise, problems can arise that project up through the legs to the back. This is not the kind of problem that should be ignored. If you are experiencing back pain after being on your feet for some time, don’t assume the problem originates with your back. It may well be foot-related (10). In which case insoles may help solve the problem.
Insoles are easy to use and produce lasting results. This is one of their most endearing qualities. Many ailments and injuries require complex and expensive treatment. An ACL tear (11), for instance, is a fairly common injury of the knee. It may require surgery, months of physical therapy and the use of a knee brace for a year or more. By comparison, plantar fasciitis or a fallen arch can often be effectively addressed with a simple pair of commercially available insoles. It would be a wonderful world indeed if all physical maladies could be addressed so quickly, effectively and cheaply.
Insoles are a cost-effective form of healthcare. You know that ACL tear we just mentioned? Do you know how much you’ll pay out of pocket for surgery if your insurance won’t cover it? Between $20,000 and $50,000 (12). In addition, the months of physical therapy we mentioned will tack many thousands more on top of that. And we haven’t even begun to talk about the cost of painkillers, anti-inflammatories and other drugs. As well as how much money will be lost due to missing work. By contrast, you can effectively deal with the pain and discomfort in your legs knees and back caused by plantar fasciitis for about the price of a large pizza.
Insoles can help improve the flexibility of your feet. When people put too much stress and strain on the muscles and tendons of the feet the feet tend to stiffen up. Flexibility is lost and even the simplest movements can be awkward and painful. This is true whether the pain is the result of plantar fasciitis, too much pounding of the heel (when running) or if the pain originates in the ball of the foot. A condition known as metatarsalgia (13). Metatarsalgia can be extremely uncomfortable and produce considerable pain. It can also produce swelling of the surrounding tissue which causes stiffness throughout the sole of the foot. Insoles can relieve metatarsalgia and the stiffness it produces.
Insoles can help prevent neuroma. Anything that produces compression of a nerve can produce neuroma (14). And since walking, running or even just standing compresses the tissue on the bottom of the feet it’s a common area of the body for neuroma to occur. Athletes often suffer from neuroma as they tend to spend long hours slamming their feet into the ground. Former athletes or people who have worked out for years are also common victims of this painful condition. Cushioned insoles can help alleviate the symptoms of neuroma. Wearing them as a preventive measure can also stave off developing neuroma in the long run.
Insoles help prevent fatigue. That’s because enduring foot pain can be a tiring experience. And that’s just as true for 20-something triathletes as it is for older individuals, who have enough things weighing on their health as it is. Wearing insoles not only alleviates the foot pain itself, not only helps strengthen the legs and back and not only reduces stress and strain on the ankles, knees and hips, it also eliminates the fatigue that all those various types of pain produce.
Insoles help your shoes last longer. Whether you are using insoles to deal with metatarsalgia or plantar fasciitis, or if you just want to fend off foot problems they’ll help your shoes last longer. Insoles absorb a large amount of the force that would otherwise be applied directly to your footwear. As a result, you’ll not only feel better your shoes will last longer too. That will also help you avoid developing future problems arising from wearing old, beat up shoes.
Q: Do insoles really work?
A: Yes, insoles really do work. Like absolutely everything, however, they may not work as well for everyone who tries them. Some people may be suffering achilles pain that is symptomatic of a larger problem that will require surgery. Bunions are another problem that can sometimes be addressed by insoles. But which, at other times, will need to be dealt with by way of surgery. In addition, a person may need to try a few different types of insoles before they find the one that provides them optimal relief. Fortunately, insoles are affordable. So trying out a few different pairs isn’t going to break the bank.
Q: Are there different kinds of insoles?
A: There are 3 generally accepted types of insoles: comfort, support and custom. Comfort insoles are the most common. They’re typically made from glycerin, gel or some kind of soft foam material. Comfort insoles are most often used by waiters, nurses and other people who suffer general aches and pains in their feet from standing too much.
Support insoles are typically fashioned from a more rigid foam. That’s because as the name suggests they’re used to supply support to the arches of the feet. By buttressing the arch they relieve pain and discomfort. People who suffer from plantar fasciitis are common users of support insoles.
Custom insoles – commonly called custom orthotics – are designed to address a specific problem a person is having. They are molded to that person’s feet and no one else’s.
Q: Are insoles and orthotics the same thing?
A: As we stated earlier commercially available insoles and custom orthotics are two different animals. Insoles like the ones on the above list are a cut above the inserts you’ll get inside a shoe from the factory. More care is taken in their design. The materials they’re made from are much higher-quality than that used to make factory inserts. And they can be removed and used in different pairs of shoes.
Custom orthotics, as we mentioned, are prescribed by a doctor to address a specific person’s specific problem. The process of making these appliances is fairly involved (15). Custom orthotics are also far more expensive than insoles. People tend to confuse insoles with orthotics because marketers often use the terms interchangeably when they really shouldn’t. That’s because somewhere in the dusty annals of market research someone determined that ‘orthotics’ sounded more high-end than insoles. Ever since, companies trying to make their insoles seem more shiny and chrome have employed the term, causing mass confusion.
Q: Can insoles help relieve back pain?
A: Yes, insoles can help relieve back pain. Many folks who live with back pain just assume it’s caused by working too hard or bad posture or just age. And it might be. But there’s also a pretty good chance that back pain is originating in their feet. Sciatica (16), for instance, is caused by compression of the spine. Most people assume it happens because they lifted something that was too heavy. But that’s not always the case. Sometimes the compression is caused by pounding the pavement mercilessly for prolonged periods of time. And, most importantly, doing so with shoes that don’t absorb shocks well or that don’t promote a proper stride. Good insoles can correct both of those problems and alleviate the pain associated with sciatica.
Q: What type of insole is best for standing?
A: Waitresses, beat cops, construction workers, nurses and others who spend their day on their feet often wind up with foot pain. Sometimes it’s localized in the heel (17) or arch. But other times it’s a more general discomfort. They don’t necessarily need insoles that provide arch support. They just need a bit more cushioning inside their shoe. For them, comfort insoles are usually the best choice. They’re available in a variety of thicknesses and can really help put the spring back in a person’s stride. Comfort insoles provide almost immediate relief and the best continue to provide that relief throughout the long day.
Q: What is the best way to wash insoles?
A: The best way to wash insoles will vary from product to product. With some you can wash them down with soapy water, rinse them thoroughly and let them air dry. Many insoles have grooves or other indentations in them. To clean inside these grooves you can use an old toothbrush. If your insoles smell that’s a sign bacteria has taken refuge in them. To get rid of the bacteria you can try soaking them in a mixture of water and vinegar for an hour or two and then cleaning them with the aforementioned soapy water. If the shoes smell too you can try sprinkling a bit of baking soda inside them to remove odors (18).
Q: Can insoles reduce my heel pain?
A: Yes, insoles are often very effective at reducing heel pain. Heel pain is sometimes the result of inadequate cushioning inside shoes. Other times it may be a symptom of plantar fasciitis. Achilles tendonitis is another common cause of heel pain. In many cases high quality insoles can alleviate heel pain caused by these conditions. That said, if the cause is something more serious – like a torn Achilles – surgical intervention may be the only viable way to obtain relief. Runners, who typically bring enormous stresses to bear on their heels – are some of the most common users of insoles.
Q: How long does a pair of insoles last?
A: This is not a question with one right answer. Basically it comes down to how much time you spend on your feet, what kind of work you do or what kind of activities you engage in, how much you weigh and what type of insole you buy. Large construction workers who spend most of their working lives on their feet may need to replace their insoles every 3 months. Same with people who run several times a week. Conversely, those with desk jobs who don’t spend lots of time upright will likely get 6 to 9 months from their insoles. Keep in mind too that insoles are like most other things in that you often get what you pay for. So you can reasonably expect that your $40 insoles will last a bit longer than your $20 insoles. Generally.
Q: What do I do if my shoes came with factory-made inserts?
A: As we mentioned above shoe manufacturers sometimes place their own inserts into their shoes to make them more comfortable. In some cases these can be reasonably effective. But in most cases they’re just a bit of window dressing. It may be possible to put your new insoles on top of these factory inserts and not experience any negative effects. In some cases however, you’ll have little choice but to remove the factory insert to make way for the new insoles. You may also need to trim the insoles a bit in order to make them fit into your shoes. But if you must trim your insoles don’t take off any more than you absolutely have to.
The best insoles help relieve pain and discomfort from an array of foot problems including plantar fasciitis, shin splints, overpronation and more. They’re easy to use, affordable and can help extend the life of your shoes as well.
Nurses, waiters, construction workers, runners, hikers and anyone else who spends a great deal of time on their feet can likely benefit from using insoles whether they have a pressing foot problem or not. In fact, insoles have been shown to help fend off the development of foot problems in the long run.
The insoles on our list represent the cream of the current crop. There is sure to be one that will provide the relief you’re after. If you are uncertain exactly which one is right for you consult your doctor.
For cpoe.org’s #1 recommended insoles, click here.